Connect with us


The Complexity of the US Healthcare System: Enemy of Access and Affordability

courtesy of

Understanding and Using Health Insurance: A Struggle for Many Americans

A recent op-ed in JAMA Network titled "Complexity in the US Health Care System Is the Enemy of Access and Affordability" sheds light on the challenges Americans face when it comes to understanding and using their health insurance. According to a Kaiser Family Foundation survey, over 80% of insured adults rate their health insurance as "good" or "excellent," but admit to having difficulty navigating the system. This is especially true for individuals in fair or poor health.

A Rube Goldberg Machine: The Perfect Metaphor for the Healthcare System

The healthcare system in the United States is often compared to a Rube Goldberg machine, a complex contraption that accomplishes simple tasks through convoluted means. Health insurance is often singled out as the main culprit, but the truth is that almost every aspect of the healthcare system is plagued by unnecessary complexity.

Third Parties and Intermediaries: Adding to the Complexity

One of the main reasons for the complexity in the healthcare system is the presence of numerous third parties and intermediaries. For instance, CMS hires Medicare Administrative Contactors to process Medicare claims, while employers who are self-insured rely on third-party administrators for network management and claims payment. Even insurers and third-party administrators subcontract to other third parties for tasks like provider credentialing and utilization review.

The Rise of Digital Health Companies: Simplification or More Complexity?

In recent years, there has been a surge in digital health companies aiming to improve the healthcare experience by digitizing different parts of the system. However, this proliferation of new players may actually be adding more complexity to the already convoluted Rube Goldberg machine of healthcare.

The Need for Simplicity in Healthcare

Complexity in the healthcare system is detrimental to patients, healthcare providers, and the overall cost of care. Rather than adding more workarounds, the focus should be on simplifying the system. Unfortunately, there is no consensus on what a simplified healthcare system should look like, making it challenging to enact meaningful change.

Simplifying the Rube Goldberg Machine: Suggestions for Innovators

Healthcare innovators should carefully consider whether their ideas are truly simplifying the system or adding to its complexity. While clever solutions may seem appealing, they may ultimately contribute to the Rube Goldberg machine of healthcare. It's time to dismantle this complex system and work towards a simpler, more effective, and more affordable healthcare system.

Continue Reading